Forensic fallibility

For the last twenty years or so we’ve gradually come to depend more and more on forensics to solve crime, with some films, books and tv series (cough CSI cough) making it look even more reliable than it perhaps actually is.  However, this recent article in The New Scientist is a real eye-opener.

Written by one of the experts in the infamous Amanda Knox case, it particularly highlights the problems when dealing with infinitesimally small traces of DNA (as was apparently the case with one of the mainstays of the prosecution case, the supposed murder weapon).  Here DNA expert Greg Hampikan reveals that the ‘miniscule’ trace of Knox’s DNA on the knife would not have been enough to count as evidence in many courts around the world – and that the Italian authorities never managed to replicate their initial results.

In spite of this (and a number of other odd quirks of evidence, or the lack of it) Knox was convicted of murder, then freed on appeal, then re-convicted, then finally cleared by the supreme court in Italy.  But overall, the case illustrates that the sort of glossy forensic certainties favoured by CSI and similar shows is a very long way from reality.


2 thoughts on “Forensic fallibility

  1. I think you make a really important point, Tess. Forensic evidence may be incredibly helpful in a lot of cases. But it’s by no means infallible; in fact, it can even be quite misleading. I suppose as time goes by it’ll get more accurate, but until then, it really does have to be taken with salt.

    • I think in most cases, where there’s plenty of it to get a result from, it’s pretty solid evidence. But we do tend to forget that not every case has helpful pools of blood!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s